I have been following the chatter about the planned Mosque on Park Avenue in New York City, i work near there and have spent a a few days praying my afternoon prayers so in following the recent spate of hateful comments from some regarding a mosque in downtown i have some opinions that i thought needed to be shared.
Europeans Took this Land from Native People
We all want to remember the past in our own way. Some of us want to get reparations for the horrors that slavery inflicted on black Americans and others that think that people need to “forget the past” and move on.
My own family are from pioneers that helped to build America into a nation. We are a mixture of the best and the worst - those humans that were enslaved and those that made slaves out of humans. We are also from the native people that called the land upon which lower Manhattan were as, if nothing else, Distant Relatives. My folks were First Nation people from what we now call Upstate NY, there is no doubt that they had a lingual and cultural connection to what we now think of as the hallowed ground of Lower Manhattan.
Many People Claim America as HOME
We all want to define American in our own way. Are we a nation of immigrants? or are we a nation of the native born? Does American mean that you are white and speak english? who can claim title to what it means to be a valid member of this pluralistic society? Who can tell others what is acceptable form of worship? I left NY yesterday to attend a wedding. My wife’s family is from Hyderbad, India but mostly have been in the USA for the better part of the last 40 years or so. They are wonderful people, somewhat insular and very focused on family - but what well-adjusted American family is not oriented that way?
It seems this question was dealt with by the Framers of the Constitution and the authors of the Declaration of Independence when they declared that all men are created equal and “endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights” to whom has the right to deny rights to any group the right to build a house of worship in this land? is that not an idea that founded this great nation?
9/11 was a Tragic Day
There are many ways to grieve. You cannot tell the world how and what are acceptable forms of grief. I know 9/11 survivor families. i know one in particular, Jeremy Glick who went on TV and debated pundits on why he did not want to go to war in the name of his fallen father. Grief has many faces. Not all are angry. Some have love in their hearts for even what they do not understand.
I add all these layers because for me the tragic events on 9/11 were very deep and un-theoretical - it was a harrowing day filled with uncertainty and the smell of death in the air. And on that day, September 11, 2001. Where were you? were you wondering where your sister was? It was an “attack on America” yes, but was it a harrowing experience for YOU personally? Did you walk past the makeshift memorials in Grand Central Terminal everyday and one day see the picture of your college football teammate?
I, Too, Know someone that DIED on 9/11 Christian DeSimone. He and i were linebackers at the University of Rhode Island in the late 90’s and he was a tragic victim who died on 9/11. He story is told here and here
.
Prayer is important.
Regardless of the hateful comments of some that condemn a mosque in downtown Manhattan, this is a place of worship and the United States was partially founded as a place where religious freedom was respected. I, the descendent of African-Americans, Native Americans, and a Native New Yorker look forward to praying just a few blocks away from where I work.
The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) told his companions: “If one of you had a stream running at his door and bathed in it five times every day, do you think any dirt would be left on him?” His companions answered: “No dirt at all would be left.” To which the Prophet replied: “That is what the five (daily) prayers are like, with which God washes away your sins.”
Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 1, Hadith 506
The Prophet once went out when the leaves were falling from the trees. He took hold of a branch and said: "Verily, when a servant of God prays seeking only His pleasure, his sins fall away just as the leaves have fallen from this tree."
Al-Tirmidhi, Hadith 199

And of course...